A History of Prop Firm Disasters

·

·

9–14 minutes
Header banner for A History of Prop Firm Disasters, white and gold text on navy background

Trust & Safety / A History of Prop Firm Disasters

Key Takeaways

  • There isn’t one way a prop firm fails. The public record shows at least four distinct patterns: platform-vendor dependency, regulatory freeze, disclosed wind-down, and public payout-backlog crisis.
  • True Forex Funds and SurgeTrader both collapsed in 2024 after MetaQuotes or a downstream vendor revoked their trading-platform licence, with no allegation of wrongdoing against either firm.
  • The CFTC’s case against MyForexFunds was dismissed in 2025 with the agency itself sanctioned, but that ended the firm years before the underlying allegations were ever tested.
  • The Funded Trader paused rather than closed in 2024 and is still rebuilding trust in 2026, a reminder that “we’re back” is a claim to scrutinise, not a track record on its own.

Every prop firm collapse gets written up afterwards as a scandal. Some were. A good number weren’t, at least not in the way the word implies. Over 2024 alone, trade press estimates put the number of retail prop firms that disappeared somewhere between 80 and 100, roughly one in every seven or eight firms operating at the start of the year. That is not a story about a handful of bad actors getting caught. It is a story about a young, largely unregulated industry built on thinner foundations than its marketing ever let on.

What follows are the disasters that are actually on the public record, sourced to trade press reporting, firm statements and, in one case, a federal court docket, rather than forum speculation. Grouped together, they show something more useful than any single scandal on its own: there isn’t one way for a prop firm to fail. There are at least four, and they say very different things about how much control a well-run firm actually has over its own survival, and about what “coming back” from a collapse actually means. That record is now kept and dated as the closures happen, in the Prop Firm Closure Tracker.

The disaster that wasn’t a scandal at all

The single most consequential event in the industry’s recent history had nothing to do with fraud. In February 2024, MetaQuotes, the developer of the MT4 and MT5 platforms that an estimated seventy to eighty percent of prop firms run on, began revoking licences from firms serving US-based clients without a proper broker relationship in place. Firms had no ownership of the platform their entire business ran on, and very little warning that the arrangement could be pulled.

True Forex Funds is the clearest example of what that dependency actually costs. The firm ceased all operations permanently on 13 May 2024, citing financial insolvency, after its MetaQuotes licence was terminated in February and a three-month scramble to migrate onto alternative technology failed to save the business. Roughly 300 traders were left owed a combined $1.2 million in payouts that were never made. Nothing in the public record alleges the firm was running a scam. It was, by its own account, a functioning business killed by the withdrawal of a licence it never controlled.

SurgeTrader followed eleven days later, on 24 May 2024, and its story is the sharper illustration of the problem. Having already lost its MetaQuotes licence in the same wave, SurgeTrader migrated to a platform run by Match-Trade Technologies. That licence was terminated too, with Match-Trade citing an inability to meet contractual obligations, and SurgeTrader closed a week later. Two platform failures, back to back, were enough to end the firm. Neither closure involved an allegation of misconduct. Both left traders locked out with no route to recover what they were owed.

The lesson isn’t that MetaQuotes did anything wrong; it was enforcing its own terms. The lesson is structural: a large share of this industry runs its entire funded-account infrastructure on licences owned by a small number of external technology vendors, and a trader has no way to know, from the outside, how exposed the firm they’ve paid is to that single point of failure.

The regulatory case that still isn’t settled

The industry’s most cited disaster is the CFTC’s action against MyForexFunds, and it is also the one most commonly misunderstood. We’ve set out the detail of what the case actually alleged, and how firms should think about the live-versus-simulated capital question it raised, in our companion piece on how to judge if a prop firm is trustworthy. What belongs here is what the case shows about how a firm actually dies.

In August 2023, the CFTC filed a fraud action against Traders Global Group, trading as MyForexFunds, and obtained an asset freeze. The firm was placed into receivership and shut down within weeks. That is the part of the story most traders know. What’s less widely reported is what happened next: in May 2025, a federal judge dismissed the CFTC’s case with prejudice and sanctioned the agency itself, finding that a CAD $31.55 million transfer the CFTC had characterised to the court as suspicious asset dissipation was, in fact, a routine corporate tax payment the agency knew about before seeking the freeze. The CFTC was ordered to pay over $3 million in fees and costs, several of its staff were placed on administrative leave, and in February 2026 a parallel Canadian regulatory proceeding ordered similar costs paid to the firm. Regulatory scares are not always real, either. For a case where the reported enforcement action simply did not exist, see no, the SEC has not charged any prop firm.

None of that means the underlying allegations were proven false; the case was dismissed on the conduct of the prosecution, not a finding on the merits, and the legal questions the case raised about live and simulated capital remain untested. What it does show, clearly and on the court record, is that a regulatory freeze can end a firm and strand its traders before a single underlying fact is ever tested in court, and that the firm can still be fighting to recover its standing years later even if it is eventually vindicated on procedure. For a trader deciding where to put an evaluation fee today, the practical risk isn’t whether a firm is guilty of anything. It’s that regulatory exposure alone, justified or not, has already proven capable of ending a firm overnight.

The quiet exits

Not every closure belongs in the same category as the two above, and lumping them together does traders a disservice. Smart Prop Trader announced in late November 2024 that it would wind down by the end of the year, stopped accepting new clients immediately, and continued honouring payouts and offering refunds to recently opened accounts through to its final day. FundingTicks announced its own closure in January 2026, following rule changes that had drawn sustained backlash from its trader base, rather than any insolvency or regulatory event.

These are still failures. A firm that closes is a firm that can no longer pay out a funded account, whatever the reason. But an orderly, disclosed wind-down that honours obligations up to the last day is a materially different event from a firm going insolvent overnight owing $1.2 million it can’t pay, or one that vanishes the moment a regulator files a complaint. How a firm behaves on its way out is itself a signal, just one that only becomes visible after it’s too late to act on for that particular firm.

The firm that paused rather than closed

Not every 2024 disaster ended in permanent closure, and The Funded Trader is the clearest example of a firm that fits neither of the categories above. Founded in 2021, TFT had grown into one of the largest and most prominent firms in the industry, reportedly serving well over 80,000 funded accounts by the time trouble hit. On 28 March 2024, co-founder and CEO Angelo Ciaramello announced the firm was “temporarily pausing all operations”, days after a wave of Trustpilot and social media complaints accused the firm of denying or delaying trader payouts, and after the comparison site PropFirmMatch.com suspended TFT from its listings over the same pattern of complaints. The firm itself later pointed to a botched migration onto the DXtrade platform, which it said had wrongfully breached a number of accounts through server errors and created a payout and support-ticket backlog it was still working through months later.

Unlike True Forex Funds or SurgeTrader, TFT didn’t disappear. Five months later, in August 2024, the firm resurfaced publicly, reporting it had sent out roughly 30% of the payouts it owed traders and addressed around 70% of the accounts affected, while continuing to review affiliate payouts that had been denied and banned accounts flagged for reassessment. The rebuild has continued since. As of 2026, The Funded Trader is still operating and still accepting new evaluations, and remains the subject of a genuinely mixed trader reputation, with recent reviews referencing both the 2024 shutdown itself and the pace of the relaunch that followed it.

That makes TFT the hardest of these cases to file neatly. It isn’t a firm that vanished owing money it will never pay, and it isn’t an orderly, disclosed wind-down either. It’s one of the industry’s largest firms breaking badly, in public, and spending the better part of two years trying to rebuild trust one payout at a time, a position that puts the burden of judgement squarely back on any trader deciding whether “we’re back” is a track record or still just a promise.

What the pattern actually shows

Line these cases up and a single-cause story about the industry stops holding together. Firms have been destroyed by fraud allegations that were later thrown out. Firms have been destroyed with no allegation of wrongdoing at all, purely because a third-party technology vendor pulled a licence. Firms have wound down in an orderly way that left traders no worse off than the closure notice implied. And at least one of the industry’s largest firms broke under a payout backlog in full public view, paused rather than closed, and is still working to rebuild trust years later. Treating “prop firm collapse” as one phenomenon with one cause, usually fraud, misses the two structural risks that sit underneath almost all of it: dependence on a small number of external platform vendors, and exposure to a regulatory grey area where enforcement action, whatever its eventual merits, can freeze a firm’s assets and its traders’ balances before anything is proven. We go into where that regulatory grey area actually stands today, and where it’s likely headed, in our full look at whether prop firm trading is regulated.

Infographic showing three distinct ways prop firms have failed: platform dependency collapse, regulatory freeze, and disclosed wind-down, white text on navy background, with named case examples

Neither risk shows up on a homepage. Neither is something a trader can fully diligence away, and no checklist, including our own, removes them entirely. What the record does support is the same conclusion our companion piece on judging a prop firm’s trustworthiness arrives at from a different angle: tenure and disclosure are the closest things to protection currently available. A firm that has survived a platform disruption, weathered scrutiny, and kept paying through it is telling you something a payout counter never can. And a firm that’s asking to be trusted again after a collapse, like The Funded Trader, deserves the same scrutiny a brand-new firm would get, not the benefit of the doubt its old name might otherwise buy it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do most prop firm collapses involve fraud?

No. The two largest 2024 closures, True Forex Funds and SurgeTrader, both happened because a third-party technology vendor revoked a platform licence, with no allegation of wrongdoing against either firm.

What actually happened with the MyForexFunds case?

The CFTC froze the firm’s assets in 2023 and it shut down within weeks. In 2025, a federal judge dismissed the case with prejudice and sanctioned the CFTC itself over how it had presented evidence. The underlying allegations were never tested on their merits, but the firm was already gone.

Is The Funded Trader still operating after its 2024 shutdown?

Yes. It paused operations in March 2024 after a payout backlog and platform migration problems, resurfaced that August, and is still accepting evaluations as of 2026, though with a genuinely mixed trader reputation that includes both the shutdown and the pace of the relaunch.


Michael Cogswell

Written by Michael Cogswell, founder of Prop Firm Briefing and co-founder of Funded Trading Plus, sold to Instant Funding in 2026. He writes from the operator’s side of the challenge model, not the affiliate’s. More about Michael →

Related coverage